Abstract

Background: A common problem that severely affects the quality of women's lives is “dysmenorrhea” or menstrual pain. In India, cultural factors in addition to social and civil educational levels play an important role with respect to health practices.

The objective of this qualitative systematic review is to investigate the different interventions used in females for “dysmenorrhea” with due attention being given as whether they are culturally acceptable and impact on social well-being.

Methods: An all-round searching strategy was used, including Scopus, Meline and Web of Sciences databases. It yielded a total of 683 records from various sources. Strictly screened Using specified criteria, 9 relevant studies were eventually selected.

With this as a guiding principle, the studies were assessed for their qualitative contributions to getting at how “dysmenorrhea” is managed in terms of traditional and modern interventions; cultural perceptions on view; and educational implications.

Results: The review found that there was a high preference for traditional and local remedies coupled with modern medical treatments. It also emphasized the need for cultural sensitivity and understanding in treating “dysmenorrhea”.

These studies particularly highlight the negative effects of “dysmenorrhea” on daily activities, education and societal participation. Comprehensive menstrual health education would form a useful basis for culturally redundant medical care is advised.

Conclusion: This review suggests that any approach to “dysmenorrhea” in India must be relevant and culturally acceptable, medical as well as education-based, concerned with both the physical effects of menstruation what is important.

It advocates an integrated approach to the management of “dysmenorrhea”, in keeping with India's socio-cultural diversity. The results suggest that future research should explore under-researched interventions and populations, and move towards inclusive, culturally congruent healthcare practices.

Chapter 1 - Introduction

1.1. Rationale for the Research Topic

Menstrual problems, a difficult part of worldwide women's health issues, are getting attention from doctors and others who make laws or study things. (Munro et al., 2018) These problems, which include PCOS and “dysmenorrhea”, cause big troubles for women in body health, mind comfort and social happiness (Bahamondes & Ali 2015).

Around the world, this goes beyond just personal health. It affects communities, money making and differences between men and women in society. New studies show that these problems are becoming more common in Indian women.

For example, a study by Lohani et al. (2019) showed that many Indian women struggle with problems during their periods like pain and unexpected cycles called menstrual irregularities. These results are more important when we look at them with the big and varied people population in India.

The choice to include people aged 18-30 is based on several important factors. This bracket includes the best years to have babies, a time when women's bodies and hormones change. This makes them more likely to experience problems with their periods.

Problems that start in this period don not just mess up everyday life. They can also affect the chances of having children and long-term health results (Munro et al., 2018). Beyond the body parts it affects, India has a mix of cultural and social things that connect with how women handle their periods. Also money is involved in this too.

Deep-seated culture rules usually hide menstruation behind secrets, keeping it quiet and spreading old stories. (Lakkawar et al., 2014) These money problems make cultural differences even harder. A large part of Indian women, especially in villages, have trouble getting sanitary products. A lack of money and not knowing better often makes them use unsafe ways to deal with periods.

Based on recent health books, this review looks at important studies by experts like Lohani (2019). These researchers have carefully written about the many problems caused during periods in India. The goal is to provide a well-founded, factual look at menstrual health programs in India by connecting them with strong school lessons.

In the end, dealing with health problems connected to menstrual issues in India is very important right now. This happens because there's a mix of physical and cultural challenges from society as well as money matters.

Also Read - Biology Assignment Help

1.2. Research Question

It is very important to know about treatments for menstrual health and their effects in real life. Thus, this research seeks to elucidate a pivotal query:
"What are the feelings and results of treatments for "dysmenorrhea" among women in India?"
This question wants to connect science research with real life experiences, making sure a complete look at the effects of these actions in India.

1.3. Relevance to the Wider Public Health Field

The study of menstrual problems, especially in India, is very important for public health issues. These health issues might seem separate at first, but they affect the whole society's happiness and equality between men and women too. (Jedynak et al., 2021) They also touch money making activities in a bigger way (Jedynak et al., 2021).

Around the world, people are starting to understand that menstrual health is very important for female reproductive health. The World Health Organisation and other global groups are pushing for more attention on menstrual health. They want it added to bigger plans about reproduction and sexual wellbeing. This worldwide push fits well with the picked topic, making it important in a wider public health talk (Babbar et al., 2022).

Women who do not get treated or are not managing their menstrual problems well might be less productive at work. This can have wider effects on the money side of life in towns and countries (Seif et al., 2015). The idea of equality between men and women is unavoidable. Getting the period is directly related to giving women more strength.

Making sure women can get good help not only fixes their health problems but also helps men and women be more equal, especially in places where power has always belonged to the fathers (Sivadasan et al., 2014). Talking about menstrual issues, especially in a big and different country like India can lead to better health results for all.

When women are given the information, tools and help to deal with menstrual problems they make getting better easier. This leads to a happier community, growth in business money stuffs happening and helps towards fairness between genders. Basically, looking at this small part of health leads to big improvements in overall well-being for everyone.

Also Read - Assignment Help Sydney

1.4. Justification for Systematic Review

The reason for choosing a systematic review, like in India dealing with menstrual problems, comes from the strong points this method brings. (Papaioannou et al., 2016) A systematic review, which is better than a normal literature review because it uses an organized method to reduce biases and make sure results can be repeated. This careful approach makes sure that the review's results come from what we know already and are presented fairly. This is important in education talk (Thomas et al., 2020).

Systematic reviews give a level of detail that is impossible to match. By going deep into the book knowledge the review can find ways, understandings and small details that might normally stay hidden. In the case of menstrual problems in India, this amount is very important. Talking about health issues is not easy because it involves various things like culture, money and society (Papaioannou et al., 2016).

A short look will not properly cover how complicated the topic really is. Also, the thoroughness of systematic reviews makes sure that no important thing is left out. By covering many different databases and including various studies, the check makes sure to get a complete understanding of what is currently known (Chen, 2017). There's a lot of research on menstrual problems, especially in different parts of India. So when it comes to knowing about these issues everything is very necessary.

Finally, the goal of a detailed review matches perfectly with what this research wants to do. There are many studies on menstrual problems in India. There is a need to gather, review and show the best information about this subject.

A careful study, with its organized way of doing things is the best choice to get this done. It makes sure that what we find gives both a deep and wide view, based on real proof shared in an unbiased manner (Munn et al., 2018). To put it simply, using a systematic review for this study is not just about methods but also plans. This choice makes sure the look into menstrual issues in India is complete and strong, finally helping out with big conversations about health to everyone.

1.5. Aim and Objectives

The main goal of this study is to carefully review and combine information from "dysmenorrhea" programs for women in India. To achieve a comprehensive understanding, the study delineates the following objectives:

1.    To check and figure out how well different methods work to help with "dysmenorrhea" in women who are 18-30 years old in India.
2.    To check how well these actions are liked, especially focusing on whether they're accepted by different social and cultural groups in India.
3.    To find out how these changes help with menstrual health and make society better..

1.6. Signposting for the Systematic Review

The review starts with a strong start. It talks about why the research is important and what it's based on. This helps to explain things clearly right from the beginning.

After the introduction, a part called "Methodology" explains how careful steps were taken to collect and study all the published works. In this part, people will learn what is included or not and the sources searched for information. They'll also understand the ways of analyzing data used in these studies.

The clear explanation given about how things were done doesn't only make the results easy to understand but also gives them real value. This makes people believe more in the research method used by others and trust its power.

The way things are done is followed by an organized and clear explanation of the results in a part called "outcomes". Using info from many studies, here we provide the experiences and results of treatments. This helps give a full view. People might want a short version that points out main ideas and patterns, along with sharing specific study results. The talk after this gets more detailed, putting the results into bigger social-cultural and money related systems. It also looks at how it affects public health.

This part helps readers better understand the importance of the research. It acts like a furnace where context and results mix together. Also, the talk will compare what was found in reviews with old studies to give an analysis that can be compared.

The last bit, which ends the check-up, gives an overview of big results and what they mean. It also talks about possible paths for more study in future. This part works as a spot for thinking, considering how the study affects public health efforts and laws based around menstrual sicknesses in India. This review mainly gives a careful, complete and thoughtful look at the topic it has chosen.

People who read, can expect a trip that helps them learn and makes things clear about menstruation health care. Also talks special chances or troubles found in India's setting.

Also Read - James Cook University Assignment Help

Chapter 2 – Literature Review

2.1. Introduction

A big number of women all over the world have "dysmenorrhea", a common problem in the area that can cause bad cramps during their monthly cycle. This is not just uncomfortable, it often leads to missing work or school and sometimes makes life harder. Even if these shows are recognized all over the world, the place and culture where they happen is complicated.

Menstruation health is a big and important topic in India, which has strong cultural habits. It's really important to learn about treatments for "dysmenorrhea" because it happens so much and some places in India have social shame around menstruation.

By learning about the various ways to treat this widespread issue in India, we can better understand it and possibly discover improved methods for dealing with it.

2.2. Justification for the Systematic Review

There are many different ways to deal with pain during periods. You can use medicine, do exercise therapy or try other treatments (Rogers et al., 2023). Many studies have been done to find out how good a specific method is. For example, Patel et al. (2015) studied if stretching exercises can work best.

On the other hand, Tewani et al. (2023) looked into how useful fasting treatments are for a long time. Using different ways like Bosu Pilates (Gotpagar and Devi, 2020) or spice-based remedies (Omidvar et al., 2019), the results sometimes give very mixed views.

These reviews can end up not matching each other well in some cases. This spread of results emphasizes the urgent need for a planned review.

This job would not only put together a lot of information but also help us understand better what works best for Indian girls. In the Indian situation, because of different culture and social groups, a detailed review is very important. In their job, doctors can benefit from a clear guide based on evidence for the best treatments.

This will help them understand and improve how they treat patients. For many Indian women dealing with bad period pain, a review might show better ways to feel better. This would improve their life quality.

2.3. Historical Context and Early Research

Dysmenorrhoea, a problem that hurts lots of women, has been studied by doctors for many years. At first, most studies focused on medicine treatments. They often used pain killers and drugs that reduce inflammation as the main way to help people feel better (Feng and Wang, 2018). As people started to recognize dysmenorrhoea as a major problem related to women's health, it was clear that studies needed to look at more than just making the symptoms easier.

With time, the way we do research began to change. Now it is completer and more comprehensive. Chaudhuri, Singh and Dhaliwal (2013) were the first to study non-drug treatments for pain. They looked at if workout sessions or heating up water bottles could work well in reducing discomfort longer term.

Afterwards others like Shah et al. (2016) tried a new path by examining whether hypnosis might help with long This time saw the start of many ways to treat pain, all aiming at fixing not only physical hurt but also mental and social problems caused by "dysmenorrhea". The new actions that came in the succeeding years brought a big change (Arora et al., 2014; Prabhu et al., 2019). 

2.4. Physical Interventions for Dysmenorrhoea

In recent years, there has been a clear change to use physical ways for handling problems with pain during periods. Many studies prove that doing exercise and stretching is a main way to lessen pain during menstruation without using drugs.

Patel et al. (2015), who were one of the first to agree with this method, showed how doing active stretch exercises can be good. The study split a group of 120 girls aged between 17 and 25 into two teams. In these groups, the group that got help was asked to do six stretching moves over 8 weeks. Before the research began, all participants were tested to determine their pain duration and intensity.

They also looked at other signs of "dysmenorrhea" using Moos Menstrual Distress Questionnaire as a guide. The group that did stretching exercises for eight weeks saw a big drop in their pain and menstrual discomfort (Patel et al., 2015). This gentle method gave relief and showed how important it is to be flexible when dealing with period problems.

Several studies then looked deeper into how aerobic exercises affect people. Stella Adaora et al. (2021) studied how aerobic exercises affect the quality of life for women with painful periods.

For this study, 60 female students aged 18 to 25 were split into two groups. The people in the help group did a 45-minute aerobics session four times every week for twelve weeks. They checked how bad the menstrual problems and pain were using words from a system (VMSS) or drawings on a line (VAS). To measure happiness, they used questionnaire that asks about life enjoyment. The group who did aerobic exercise for 12 weeks saw less pain and a big improvement in life quality.

But, the study had some problems. It only included a few people and didn't know much about normal menstrual cycles for those women involved or anything called "dysmenorrhea.". Just like that, Arora et al. (2014) started to study a program of exercise on the treadmill for 12 weeks. In this study, 60 ladies aged between 19 and 24 years were chosen from school.

Then they split them into two groups of thirty each. The group that received help did aerobics on a treadmill for 12 weeks, three to five times per week. The results were checked through things like Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and Verbal Multidimensional Score (MDS). Also, they looked at how many sanitary napkins are used in one day when bleeding is the worst.

They also tested Quality of Life using a questionnaire called SF-36 survey. Their results matched with what Stella Adaora found. They saw clear cuts down in pain and suffering plus better quality of life. But, keep in mind that the small number of people involved may limit how widely this study can be applied.

However, the world of physical actions isn't only about exercising. Chaudhuri et al. (2013) did a study comparing how well exercise works against using a warm water bottle. Both ways showed good results, but the first one gave a better way to manage things. In the same way, Gurpreet et al. (2018) offered a cool mix of activities with heat therapy.

In this study, a group of 60 healthy women who were not married and in the age range from 18 to 25 years was chosen. They all had "painful periods". These ladies were then split into two groups with each having thirty people. The first group did exercise along with heat treatment during their period. The control group only got the hot treatment.

At the end of treatment, how much pain people felt was measured with a thing called Visual Analog Scale. Their work showed that combining exercise with heat treatment is better than just using heat by itself. In addition, a study by Tharani et al. (2018) compared stretching exercises with aerobic dance activities. Their findings showed that aerobic dance is better for lowering pain and stress related to primary dysmenorrhoea.

Also Read - Zoology Assignment Help

2.5. Alternative Physical Therapies for Dysmenorrhoea

These days, lots of treatments for menstrual pain are out there but new ways like doing exercises have become very popular. These give a full treatment to help with the ouch during periods. These treatments, from simple movement exercises to needle therapy, give safe help without the bad effects that can happen with medicine-based options. Desai's (2022) literature-based review showed how important physical therapy is in treating painful periods.

From 2014 to 2021, Desai looked at literature. He explained how exercises that strengthen your core and stretch muscles help make menstrual pain less strong and improve the strength of those main stomach muscles. This discovery shows that physiotherapy is more than just relieving pain. It also helps improve overall physical health (Desai, 2022).

Unnisa et al. (2022) did a study to look for ways other than medicine that might help with pain during menstruation called dysmenorrhoea. Their results told a strong story, showing how effective these steps can be in dealing with the health problems caused by dysmenorrhoea. After the intervention, there was a change in how people saw non-drug treatments.

This showed that more and better spread of these medical options is needed (Unnisa et al., 2022). In a study by Agrawal and Ahmed (2021), they looked closely at how stretching exercises worked against core strengthening exercises in dealing with primary dysmenorrhoea.

Both modalities yielded promising results. Importantly, people used fewer pain pills and this is a big step towards managing their health naturally without drugs. This study agrees that both stretching and making the core part of body stronger are good choices. They should be looked at more in healthcare places soon.

Kaur et al. (2017) looked at an interesting area. They compared moving connective tissue with kinesio-taping method. The study that lasted for three periods showed both ways as strong in reducing how much menstrual pain and other problems hurt.

It's interesting that the two didn't change much. This suggests each one can be adjusted to suit personal choices and needs. This discovery shows the variety of different physical treatments that can be used. Each one has its own special benefits (Kaur et al., 2017). Finally, the study by Abhijna and Shetty (2023) compared acupuncture against a normal hip bath for treating primary dysmenorrhoea.

The results were revelatory. Acupuncture was found to be better at stopping bad cramps than hydrotherapy, making it a possible choice for other physical therapy options.

In the end, the world of non-standard physical treatments for menstrual pain is big and different. Menstrual pain can be helped a lot by therapies like physiotherapy, kinesio-taping and acupuncture.

These treatments are very powerful against menstrual pain. (Desai, 2022) shows how useful these methods are all together while (Kaur et al., 2017) talks about the little details that make this extra. 

2.6. Fasting and Diet in Dysmenorrhoea Management

Resarcher have been curious about how food and nutrition can help fix different health issues. In a study by Tewani et al. (2023), they investigated how fasting helped treat "dysmenorrhea". This is a common issue for many women all around the world. They looked at if changing what you eat can help ease this problem.

52 people who were 18 to 24 years old took part in a study. They split them into two groups. The control group kept eating like usual, while another team had to do a careful ten day fast.

They only took in 500 kcal or less every single day. This question gave important discoveries. Many signs, like pain and tummy aches linked to "dysmenorrhea" were much lower in the group that fasted.

In addition, there were big changes that made the lives of these people generally better. The study by Tewani et al. (2023) helps understand how fasting for therapy may be good.

This study shows that a special diet done during fasting helps in treating "dysmenorrhea". However, it is important to note that understanding exactly how specific foods eaten by these patients affect their condition was not the focus of this research.

But these results show that we need to think about complete treatments for the body like changes in what you eat when dealing with menstrual pain. Fasting for healing seems to work well in taking care of painful periods, according to Tewani et al. (2023).

2.7. Spices and Natural Remedies in Dysmenorrhoea Management

The whole-body view of health often points out the healing power of natural stuff. When it comes to dealing with menstrual pain, some popular spices have been noticed as top choices. Omidvar et al. (2019) did a medical experiment to see how well some spices, specifically ginger, dill seeds and cumin worked in treating dysmenorrhoea.

In their research, 31 women with menstrual pain were given spices to use. They split them into three groups, and each group used a different spice from the ones already mentioned earlier on. The eating habits were kept up for three menstrual cycles, and the results were carefully written down. The results showed that dill seeds were the best at relieving pain, and ginger came close behind them.

On the other hand, cumin didn't help much with pain but it made general body symptoms like sweating without being warm and feeling tired or having a sore back better. Omidvar et al.'s (2019) study shows that spices traditionally used have healing abilities. It highlights how these might help manage pain during periods without medicine.

The main problem with the results of these studies is that they used a small group. This could make it hard for others to use their findings as an example. However, this study not only gives more reasons to include natural remedies in treatments but also appeals to those looking for easy and non-invasive options. (Omidvar et al., 2019).

2.8. Mind-Body Practices in Dysmenorrhoea Management

The connection between mind and body is very deep. Many studies have looked at how it can help ease menstrual pains. Prabhu et al. (2019) did a great study about how good yoga positions from ancient India can be compared to exercising our bellies in coping with menstrual pain.

In a study with 80 people aged 18 to 22, it was found that both yoga poses and core exercises can help reduce the pain of menstruation. Importantly, the treatments worked well and were also cheap. They offered a good extra or alternative choice to older ways of getting better.

Prabhu et al. (2019) say that whole body mind practices help ease period pain. This adds more options for treatments without drugs or medicine. But, the study could also be restricted by how "dysmenorrhea" and stress are connected in different groups of women.

2.9. Psychological Interventions in Dysmenorrhoea Management

Therapies for the mind give a special way to help with "dysmenorrhea", which is hard to treat. Shah et al. (2016) did a great study to see how good hypnosis can be as another kind of treatment. A study was done on 50 nursing students who had painful periods.

They were placed into two groups: One group got hypnosis and the other received medicine called NSAID (Ibuprofen). The group who tried hypnosis had long-lasting pain relief that was better than the short-term help from NSAID. This shows how powerful hypnosis can be, not just to help but as a strong choice for handling painful periods.

Nayak et al. (2022) suggested a study plan to show how meditation and yoga might help teenage girls with primary dysmenorrhoea. Yoga has exercises but its heart is also connected to mind practices. These calm the person's thoughts and feelings inside them. The study believes that by mixing these two methods, it could help ease the pain and upset caused by dysmenorrhoea.

Together, the studies by Shah et al. (2016) and Nayak et al. (2022) highlight how important mental help treatments are becoming more popular every day. They talk about a whole-person approach, going beyond the limits of normal medicine treatments. They support methods that put both brain and body in sync to lessen painful period cramps.

2.10. Current Debate in Dysmenorrhoea Interventions

The discussion about treatments for painful periods has changed a lot. It started from old ways of helping people and moved to more modern, proven solutions that are based on information. In history, help was usually based on cultural activities and personal stories. But with science and studies getting serious, new ways to help people have shown up. These include medicine-based treatments as well as methods not involving drugs at all.

The mixing of old and new solutions can be seen in the works by Omidvar et al. (2019) and Prabhu et al. (2019). Omidvar et al. looked into the healing effects of spices like ginger, dill seeds and cumin while Prabhu et al.. focused on how yoga postures can be a treatment for health issues. The first one is linked to old ways of thinking, while the second stands for new balanced methods that combine mind and body.

The discussion is mainly about whether non-medicine treatments or medicine interventions work better. Desai (2022) showed that physiotherapy, a way to help people without medicine, is very useful for handling dysmenorrhoea. He also said that exercises like core strengthening and stretching can greatly reduce how bad the menstrual pain feels during this time.

On the other hand, Shah et al. (2016) focused on hypnosis. They said it could be a good choice instead of NSAIDs. This dichotomy epitomises the ongoing deliberation: Should treatments mainly focus on natural, non-invasive approaches or should medicines supported by scientific data continue to rule the healing scene? In the ongoing argument, a big issue is about how interventions are measured.

Armour et al. (2019) showed that more than half of young ladies used self-care for period pain, with paracetamol as the common headache remedy. But, its success was not sure because only 11% went to the doctor for their pain. This raises a pertinent question: Should we measure the success of treatments mostly by what patients say, which gives a personal feeling about their life experience? Or should it be checked through medical tests that give an unbiased look at how effective those therapies are?

In short, the argument about treatments for painful periods is complicated and has many different sides. It moves between respecting old knowledge and accepting new scientific ways. As people keep looking into different treatments like Bosu Pilates and others, the search for what works best is always changing. It shows how complicated women's health can be.

2.11. Gaps in Current Literature

The growing number of writings about treatments for period pain, while interesting, shows obvious missing parts that need more study. A big gap is the lack of long-term studies to see how well an intervention works over time.

Tewani and others (2023) looked at how fasting for treatment can help with bad menstrual pain. The results were good, but they only studied a short time period. A longer study would show if the good things from these actions last for a long time or they become less effective over time. Most studies, like Patel et al. (2015) and Stella Adaora et al. (2021), mostly look at one kind of exercise method -- either stretching or aerobic workouts done with movements. The power of combining different ways, known as multi-modal approaches, is not yet well studied.

These ways of mixing things might improve treatment results. They could offer a more complete plan for dealing with painful periods, known as dysmenorrhoea. Lastly, the books or writings often miss talking about how strong our culture and beliefs can be. This is particularly true when we talk about different cultures like those found in India.

Omidvar and others (2019) talked about how spices usually used have helped in managing pain during periods. This suggests that there are long-standing beliefs around health for women. However, not much writing looks closely at the complex patterns of cultural beliefs and practices along with native knowledge systems.

It doesn't discuss how these things affect ways to manage painful periods in India. This means that while we have useful information, it also shows the need for more detailed and long-term research to fill gaps in what we know about treatments for dysmenorrhoea. 

2.12. Conclusion

Many women's quality of life is affected by dysmenorrhoea. So, there is needed a big and inclusive way to handle it. Instead of separate efforts, a mix of body and mind treatments along with other kinds will make for complete help. By combining the good things about exercises, peace of mind practices and old cures a mix approach can handle all parts this disease. It brings comfort to those suffering. The current books we read, which are many in number, show some topics that need more looking into.

Future work must deal with the lack of long-term studies and needing to do research on different ways for intervention. By exploring these new areas, scientists can not only add to what we already know but also find new and stronger ways to help with painful periods. In a colourful and different country like India, the importance of actions created for its special social-cultural environment can't be too high.

Getting to know and using traditional knowledge, ways of doing things, and beliefs can help in making better treatments that people find more acceptable. These traditional treatments can use the power of old customs and join them with new scientific ideas. This makes a strong mix that connects with what most Indian people believe in.

In short, the process of finding the best treatment for painful periods is still going on. If we look at everything together, focus on areas that need more study and understand the importance of methods tied to culture, there is a hopeful future with chances for big discoveries.

Chapter 3 – Methodology

3.1. Introduction

The reliability and accuracy of a systematic review's results heavily depend on its method. The main goal is to set up a reliable and open system for collecting, studying, and combining literature. This will give detailed unbiased results (Snyder 2019). This way helps measure treatment for pain during periods in Indian women by setting up a step-by-step method.

It checks all important information using the same rules so nothing is missed out. This part tells us about how the systematic review works. At the start of this essay, there's a big explanation about how we found stuff. It tells you what databases were used and which words we searched for exactly. Also, it includes important extra sources too.

To focus on the best and important studies, their reasons for adding or leaving them are explained next. In the next sections, you will get more details about how to use quality checks on chosen articles. This includes finding out what's needed and using proper tools for this job. This makes sure a thorough and regular check of the study's quality.

The chapter ends with a summary about how to get and study data. It also provides details on showing the results in an organised way. These findings can be understood and put together with the aid of this solid structure. The thoroughness and careful approach shown by the systematic review can be seen through its well-structured process.

3.2. Search Strategy

3.2.1. Databases Used

For this review of many studies, some well-known databases were used to make sure we picked lots and different papers about "dysmenorrhea" treatments. Medline was picked because it does a lot of medical and health research, can help understand different ways to treat problems.

It is famous for having a huge storehouse of science information written by experts (AlRyalat, 2019).

Scopus gave a bigger view by including many methods for managing "dysmenorrhea" in its wide coverage of scientific papers, especially those about health. (Gusenbauer and Haddaway said this in 2020) Lastly, knowing the subject well is made easier by Web of Sciences.

It covers a wide area of study that includes social sciences, life sciences and arts or humanities (Halevi et al., 2017). These databases were combined to create a complete and different collection of studies. They covered many methods and viewpoints needed for smart understanding of "dysmenorrhea" treatments.

3.2.2. Search Terms and Keywords

The way of finding literature for the review was very carefully made. Special words and "or", "and" were used to find all studies on treatments for stomach aches during periods (Bramer et al., 2017). The big word "dysmenorrhea" includes phrases like "monthly cramps" and pain during periods for many terms that relate to discomfort in girls' time of month.

Also, the word "non-drug treatments" focused on studies that looked at different medicine options. Using "India" and "young Indian women", the emphasis was on what's happening in India.

This search method greatly relied on using Boolean operators (Bramer et al., 2018). Like "dysmenorrhea" and treatments without medicine, or "dysmenorrhea" in Indian girls, the word "AND" was used to join up different thoughts. This made sure that articles found discussed both parts of learning what we need to know. The researcher also used "OR" to include different words like saying both, "period pain" and "monthly cramps."

We included info about special treatments such as yoga, exercise changes diet swaps and talking with a counselor. All these words were mixed together in the search using something called boolean operators. They put them together nicely with main keywords for example: “dysmenorrhea”.
 

Table 1: Search Terms and Keywords
(Source: Researcher)

3.2.3. Search Framework

The way to look for the big study was carefully planned, using SPIDER tool which helped find many studies about treatments of "menstrual cramps causing pain" (Bramer et al., 2017). The main word "pain during period time" was mixed with terms like "Menstrual cramps." This assisted in handling a large amount of words about menstrual pain. Furthermore, the word "non-drug therapies" considered studies on options to medicines. Using "India" and "Indian girls" helped to make the topic more about India.

The SPIDER method, good for qualitative research, was used in this review of the search process (Amir-Behghadami, 2021). This helped to arrange and improve it. The term SPIDER (Sample, Phenomenon of Interest, Design, Evaluation and Research type) helps to make a search larger and more complicated than traditional methods like PICO.

It is especially helpful for qualitative studies that focus on understanding stories or opinions from people involved in the subject being studied (Feizi & Soheili 2021). The Sample part was about Indian girls dealing with "dysmenorrhea". This made sure the study looked at certain types of people.

The Important Thing considered different non-medicine ways to treat "dysmenorrhea", like exercises, diet and talking therapies. The Design part wasn't just about one kind of study style, so it let in many different ways to do qualitative research. The check was made by looking at how well and strongly these actions worked on "painful periods".

After that, the type of research used was qualitative. This helped gather deep information and understanding from the people taking part in it. The SPIDER method made sure they did a careful job looking at many different kinds of study related to what needed answering (Zafar et al., 2023).

Table 2: SPIDER Framework
(Source: Researcher)

3.3. Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria

Table 3: Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
(Source: Researcher)

The good reasons for the chosen rules in this careful review are very important to make sure that research is useful and strong (Pati & Lorusso, 2018). The researcher carefully chose studies that were published between 2013 and 2023. The researcher did this to get the newest research on ways to help with "dysmenorrhea".

This time lets people improve ways to treat problems without drugs. It also shows the latest thoughts and new changes in dealing with this condition (Ryan, 2017). Looking at recent studies is important because it means the actions being tested are in line with what doctors do now and society's changes, especially when talking about women in India.

Another mindful choice is to stress qualitative research designs. Qualitative studies give detailed and rich information about patient feelings, ideas, and the surrounding factors that affect "menstrual pain" treatments. This lines up with research aims to understand complicated or personal parts of managing this issue which may need more than just numbers. Menstrual health is very private and affected by culture. Qualitative research can give important views that help in caring for people better (Bleiker et al., 2019).

Studies focusing on Indian women take into account the differences of their cultures and where they live, when looking at "dysmenorrhea" or painful periods management in India. This focus on the area is important because people's, beliefs and practices about culture as well as access to healthcare can greatly affect how women perceive menstrual health (Chen, 2017).

The review wants to find helpful and important facts by focusing on that part of the population. These rules make sure that the study is meant for what's needed, rating well above average only in Indian women with "dysmenorrhea." The details are chosen to make sure a balance between going deep and looking broad, allowing you to understand the topic well within what's set. (Thomas et al., 2020).

3.4. Quality Assessment

3.4.1. Choice of Quality Assessment Tool

They chose the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) for checking quality in their big study because it puts more focus on qualitative research. They picked this method owning to a few reasons. Long et al. (2020) said that CASP is well-known for being great at checking if qualitative research works.

This fits the needs of this current study because it gives a solid plan to check how honest, dependable, and important things are studied in investigations. Its complete list makes it easier to check each study's quality. This helps the review results depend only on good research (Buchheri and Sharifi, 2017).

3.4.2. Application of the Tool

The CASP checklist, which has questions to test the truthfulness and importance of a study's results. This was used for full examinations of each chosen article (Purssell in 2020). The questions looked at the goals of a study, how it was done and thought-out. They also asked about getting people involved in research, methods to collect information details from them but always remembering ethics matters. Also they talked about what is found out and if any decisions were practical (Quigley et al., 2019).

The list was carefully completed for each study, while the judges clearly explained their responses. This process focused on the good and bad things of a study. It also looked at how well it was done (Buccheri and Sharifi, 2017). It allowed a careful look at how the planning and execution of the study could impact its conclusions about treatment for "painful monthly bleeding" in Indian women, especially.

Because the CASP tool is so complete, it looked at each study's effect on everything instead of just as a task to do (Long et al., 2021). This method was very important for showing the gaps and possible things to research more about "dysmenorrhea" treatments today. (Ma et al., 2020)

To make sure everyone knows the reasons behind including every study in this review, there will be full checks of each article found only in extra information. This helps to provide clear details for readers.

The finished CASP checklists will be in these extra parts, along with notes about the evaluation and comments. These help us understand how decisions were made (Hannes & Bennet 2017). This adding will make the review more believable.

It will also be a big help for people in future who want to study systematic reviews and qualitative research checks (Majid and Vanstone, 2018). To put it simply, using the CASP tool was very important in this review. It helped make sure that its results were true and could be trusted. The add-on sections' complete check will make this school project even more clear and precise.

3.5. Data Extraction and Analysis

3.5.1. Data Extraction Table

A key part of this careful study was the data table, thoughtfully made to get important facts from each added research. This helped look closely at treatments for "dysmenorrhea" in Indian women (Kim et al., 2017). The focus on being clear and careful in making this table matches the quality nature of the study being looked at.
The table was divided into several categories, each of which had a distinct function in summarising the research findings:

Study Identification:

This part used important but necessary details like the author(s), publication year, and study name. This data made it simple to quickly look up and check sources.

Study Design:

In this case, the special design of every research was written down. This could be a random control study or different studies like looking for patterns over time or cross-comparing information from different groups and more in-depth detailed work. This group gave a look into the way each study was done.

Study Setting and Population:

The details of where the study was done (rural or urban) and who it included in terms of people's age, sex, etc. were part added to the report too. This data was very important to know the meaning and use of what they found out.

Intervention(s) Studied:

This important part talked about what type of help each study looked at. Sometimes it was things like exercises, eating different foods or mental treatments or a mix of all these options. We also recorded details like how long, often and strong the action was.

Outcome Measures:

The main and secondary results of the studies were clearly described. This covered relief from pain, making life better, taking care of mental health and other useful measurements.

Key Findings:

In this part, the main outcomes of each research were briefly explained. This made it easy to look up what their study found out quickly.

The table that gets data is made to hold lots of information. It helps us see details about what each study adds and where they fall short (Munn et al., 2018).

This careful collecting of information helped look closely at methods being used for "dysmenorrhea" in Indian women. It also made sure the study results were important and related to these girls.
 

Table 4: Data Extraction Table
(Source: Researcher)

3.5.2. Methodological Quality Assessment

In this systematic review on "dysmenorrhea" therapies for Indian girls, we carefully check the quality of all papers included. Boland, et al. (2017) said that checking this is important for making sure the review's results are real and reliable. To do this, they used a careful method.

They looked at each study's way of doing things to check if it was good and followed the rules for research. Then they checked closely how data were collected and analyzed (Xiao & Watson, 2019).

Important parts of judging the quality included checking if goals were clear, how good the study design match was with questions asked. Also important: effectiveness of selecting right people for test and completeness in studying results (Cumpston et al., 2019).

The person doing the research took care to see how each study dealt with confusing things, handled unfair situations and gave proof for its choices about methods. This check was more than just a list; it really looked carefully at the good and bad things of every study.

The test results will be fully shared, providing a clear and honest report of the quality methods used in studies included in the review. The advice from the careful checking of studies is strong because they use good science and proof details (Munn et al, 2018).

3.6. Results Presentation Strategy

A systematic review on treatments for "dysmenorrhea" is shown in an organized way, making sure it is clear and useful. This approach is needed to see all parts of the therapies used for "dysmenorrhea."

It also helps with understanding what their outcomes are like in India. For easy understanding of the study points, who took part and what kind of actions were used. Also how things changed as results are shown from a first look at arranged data (Kim et al., 2017). This basic look shows how wide and different this research area is.

The results give more details about each group after showing a general picture. To better understand how to use the results, details of who was involved—like their age group, background and where they lived are given. (Boland et al., 2017)

To know how "dysmenorrhea" treatments work different on different groups of women in India, we need this specific feature. Then, the different types of intervention are talked about more. This gives a simple overview of all the medicine and non-medical methods used in research projects. This part lists many treatments for dealing with "painful periods" by explaining how well they work, if they are right or wrong and can be easily done.

When looking at the outcomes, the analysis focuses on how well treatments help with reducing pain and making life quality better. It also checks for any negative effects or problems found. The way we check if studies are done well is included in showing the results.

This lets us carefully look at how strong the proofs are. This understanding is important to see the real effect of these actions and guide future healthcare treatment and advice for patients (Xiao & Watson, 2019).

This study talks about the good things and bad parts of what we know now. It also shows where more research is needed (Cumpston et al., 2019). This method helps put together a lot of information so it's simpler to comprehend and understand (Hannes and Bennet, 2017).

3.7. Summary

The method of doing the review is a tough and careful way that's needed for studying treatments on "pain during period" in Indian women. The method uses a clear plan to search for information.

It helps collect many good and important papers from different databases like Medline, Scopus and Web of Sciences. The method uses certain keywords and the SPIDER search system to find many types of studies.

This increases how complete a review is. The well-defined and proven rules for choosing what to include or leave out make the review more accurate and relevant to its goals. The research being discussd is good and reliable because it went through a careful check using a tool called CASP.

In simple words, this way is the foundation of an action-by-action check. It makes certain that the results are full and supported by solid evidence. The process's thoughtful planning and execution has assisted us in understanding better remedies for "bad periods" in India. This has greatly impacted research about women's health.

Chapter 4: Results

4.1. Introduction

The issue of “dysmenorrhea” is noteworthy because it greatly reduces the standard of living for Indian women. It synthesises and evaluates earlier studies in order to demonstrate India's various strategies and the efficacy of those strategies.

The treatment for “dysmenorrhea” is investigated and interpreted in this study. The researcher conducting this study to learn more about the relative merits of conventional and alternative medicine.

This study's contribution to healthcare policy and education going forward is the emphasis it puts on readily available, culturally appropriate solutions. Focusing on research and limitations in practical application, the study improves knowledge. In this important area of women's health, it is possible to build upon the results of additional studies.

4.2. Results of Search Strategy and Study Selection

 


This systematic review made use of a thorough search strategy that encompassed a multitude of databases. This allowed us to be confident that the method was really used for in-depth topic research. Scopus, Medline, and Web of Scineces—the three most comprehensive databases—were queried again after the initial search, yielding 683 records.

This large collection showed that interventions for “dysmenorrhea” are of interest to Indian women, which implies a need for additional research in this area. To narrow the search, it was required to remove duplicates, which are common in systematic reviews.

There are now 354 uniquely identifiable records. This exemplifies the interconnectedness of scientific research and the frequency with which studies from different databases intersect. Throughout the screening process, the researcher strictly followed the inclusion and exclusion criteria and performed a comprehensive analysis of these records.

Finding studies conducted in India that addressed “dysmenorrhea” treatment was the main objective of this inquiry. At this point, 321 records were discarded from further consideration due to their lack of relevance to the current topic or their failure to fulfil the requirements for a qualitative research study, for instance several did not align with the setting of India with a large majority of the excluded studies were quantitative.

To establish eligibility, the remaining 33 papers were reviewed. All of the studies were double-checked to make sure they were up to par in terms of quality and relevance. This level does not take into account studies that were performed outside of India, studies that are not related to research, or studies that use mixed or qualitative approaches.

This rigorous reduction was needed to identify the most relevant studies for discussion. Eleven studies were separated in the collection. The studies also met additional requirements, such as evaluating “dysmenorrhea” interventions in Indian women.

This chapter presents the PRISMA Flow Diagram, which shows item selection and search. From search to selected studies and methodological procedures, visual help provides clarity and transparency.

A systematic review found that the research selection and search technique was extensive and exact. The review is based on a large and respectable body of research due to their meticulous and demanding academic methodology.

4.3. Results of Study Characteristics

The studies in this review illuminated the difficulties of treating “dysmenorrhea” in Indian women. Each study contributes to our understanding of the illness differently due to its approach and focus. An experienced gynaecologist helped Shukla and Sanjeev (2022) conduct a cross-sectional study in India.

The study examined whether Indians knew enough about feminine hygiene to avoid illness. This study's findings emphasise the importance of personal hygiene in menstrual health.

In Rani, Sharma, and Singh (2916) reviewed Chandigarh data to determine the prevalence of “dysmenorrhea” in adolescents and its effects. Besides being methodologically sound, the multistage stratified sample provides valuable information about menstrual hygiene behaviours and knowledge.

In an exploratory research aimed at identifying the primary “dysmenorrhea” symptoms, Kavitha and Jeyalakshmi (2013) used ten adolescent females as participants. The authors demonstrate the impact of primary “dysmenorrhea” on everyday life and the need of assistance via the use of theme analysis.

Ahuja, Sharma, and Singh (2016) conducted a cross-sectional study in Chandigarh that was highly similar to the work that Rani et al. had done, expanding upon Rani et al.'s research on the effects of “dysmenorrhea” on everyday life and academic achievement. This study's results emphasise the wide range of both physical and mental symptoms that are present in this illness.

The beliefs of schoolgirls in Pune regarding menstruation were investigated in a qualitative ethnographic study (Chothe et al., 2014). According to the research, schoolgirls face health issues in addition to misunderstandings.

Since “dysmenorrhea” is so common, Roy et al. (2018) reviewed all of the available Indian herbal remedies for the condition. This investigation was helpful to conventional medicine.

Early education has been shown to significantly reduce “dysmenorrhea” in children from Central India, according to Chhabra et al. (2017). The researcher derived this conclusion from what we knew before menstruation. Here, the importance of a well-educated childhood is highlighted. Sangwan and Vashisht (2017) found high prevalence of “dysmenorrhea” in their study of menstrual patterns in Haryana.

The importance of increasing public health literacy is highlighted by this finding. Because “dysmenorrhea” and premenstrual syndrome are so common among teenagers, Pandit (2014) found that menstrual problems in Pune necessitate health education. Due to the distinctive nature of the samples and results, these studies significantly contribute to the body of knowledge on “dysmenorrhea” in India. 
 

4.4. Results of Study Quality Assessment

The CASP criteria evaluate the studies' scientific rigour and importance in order to determine their quality grade. Even in the study by Pandit, S.B. (2014), the research goals were not thoroughly reviewed to ensure they were realistic and fit within the study's scope. The level of detail used to describe the objectives determines the research's credibility. Not all studies may benefit from using qualitative methods.

Consider the work of Shukla and Sanjeev (2022), whose aims and methodology align with those of qualitative research methods. Rani (2016) and Ahuja et al. (2016) are among the studies that have demonstrated a decrease in alignment evidence. Both

Kavitha and Jeyalakshmi (2013) and Chothe et al. (2014) employed study designs that align with the investigational objectives, indicating that careful design was employed.According to Shukla and Sanjeev's (2022) research, all studies follow established ethical guidelines and properly handle ethical issues. A lot of work went into the data analysis so the studies' results could be believed.

Noteworthy works include Chothe et al. (2014) and Kavitha and Jeyalakshmi (2013) as they had clear demarcation of aims and objectives and also provide reliable information with respect to the inclusion criteria of the systematic review.

In conclusion, Roy et al. (2018) and Chhabra et al. (2017) show that the studies make a significant contribution to understanding the findings and improving “dysmenorrhea” interventions. Despite the fact that some parts, especially the researcher-participant dynamic, require further clarification, the review highlights the variety and excellent quality of the included studies.

However, Ahuja et al. (2016) and Rani et al. (2016) failed to clearly state their approach to participant interaction in order to move forward with the quality evaluation which impacts the quality of the evidence provided by the systematic review.

Conversely, a more transparent and honest relationship was shown by Chothe et al. (2014) and Kavitha & Jeyalakshmi (2013), which is crucial for the integrity of qualitative research. with Sangwan and Vashisht (2017), S.B. also mentioned. highlighted the importance of conducting the studies in accordance with ethical standards.

Chothe et al. (2014) found that researchers cared about participants' well-being and the study's ethics. Roy et al. (2018) and Chhabra et al. (2017) improved previous studies by using rigorous data analysis. If this exhaustive investigation is accurate, the scientific community and field may experience real-world consequences. All studies present their findings clearly and succinctly to reach a wider audience. Shukla and Sanjeev (2022) must be prioritised. All studies agree that research is essential to CASP review.

Chothe et al. (2014) and Kavitha and Jeyalakshmi (2013) studied “dysmenorrhea” and its management in India, improving our understanding. In order to prove this, many studies have used different points of view. In addition to fostering more robust discussion, this joint effort influences healthcare policy and practice in India.
 

4.5. Results of synthesis

The key findings from selected studies are synthesised to provide a complete picture of menstrual health issues, including “dysmenorrhea”, in women from India. All of the viewpoints, methods, and findings in Pandit (2014) are diverse, but they all stress the same core issues. Indian women, according to gynaecologists (Shukla and Sanjeev, 2022), fail to understand the significance of practicing good personal hygiene.

Adolescents in Chandigarh had high rates of “dysmenorrhea”, according to a comparative study by Rani et al. (2016). Researching the effects of “dysmenorrhea” on daily life and regional variations in menstrual knowledge allowed them to get a microcosmic perspective on the problem. Studying the mental and physical toll that primary “dysmenorrhea” takes on young women in 2013 was a joint effort by Kavitha and Jeyalakshmi.

The importance of knowledge and support in maintaining regular menstrual cycles is highlighted by the analysis of these themes. This research is similar to that of Ahuja et al. (2016), who look at how “dysmenorrhea” affects everyday life and school. This supports that monthly irregularities greatly impact young women's capacity to study and live on their own.

Chothe et al. (2014) conducted an anthropological research that aimed to understand how schoolgirls perceive menstruation. Important for future studies on menstrual physiology and anatomy, this study expands our understanding of the social and cultural factors influencing menstrual health. From the perspective of complementary and alternative medicine, Roy et al. (2018) investigated “dysmenorrhea” herbal treatments.

Period pain treatments and the pharmacognostic evaluation of these drugs are discussed from a different angle in this article. Period health education is the central focus of both Sangwan and Vashisht (2017) and Chhabra et al. (2017).

Both the “dysmenorrhea” and premenarche awareness symptoms were examined in the 2017 studies conducted by Chhabra et al. (2027). But rural health awareness is something that Sangwan and Vashisht (2017) stress. Health education and effective management of menstrual health were the focal points of a 2014 Pune investigation into menstrual issues by Pandit (2014).

These studies shed light on the current situation of menstrual health in India, including the obstacles, needs, and possible treatments that are out there. This area of research has seen a harmonisation and systematic organisation of fundamental and vital concerns, as shown by the theme map in the last chapter.

4.6. Thematic Analysis

4.6.1. Awareness and Education on Menstrual Health

One of the chosen studies aimed to raise awareness and educate people about menstrual health. The significance of information transmission in the healing process of Indian women's periods was emphasised in this study. There is an urgent need for educational interventions regarding feminine hygiene, according to the findings of the cross-sectional study by Shukla and Sanjeev (2022).

In order to illuminate ignorance and its effects, this study investigates gynaecologists' points of view. Chhabra et al. (2017) sought to understand the effect of premenarche education on menstrual health in Central India by studying the correlation between premenarche knowledge and reports of “dysmenorrhea”. Their study's results suggest that girls' pre-menarche knowledge might influence their menstrual experiences and coping mechanisms.

According to Pandit (2014), the high incidence of menstrual disorders among teenagers and the significance of health education in schools are both brought to light. Since the focus of this research is on educational interventions, we hear a lot about period health education and awareness. Roy et al. (2018) stresses the significance of traditional remedies in the treatment of “dysmenorrhea”.

They showed how scientific methods can validate traditional knowledge through their study on herbal formulations, which expands the range of options for menstrual health management. Although these studies address different aspects of menstrual health, they all stress the need for public education and awareness. The data summary shows that improving menstrual health requires filling in the gaps in our understanding of both modern medical treatments and traditional rituals. Indian women might benefit from better decision-making, healthier coping mechanisms, and general well-being if they were taught about menstrual health.

4.6.2. Impact of “dysmenorrhea” on Daily Life

Results from the studies that are now being considered show that “dysmenorrhea” impacts people's daily lives in many different ways. In Chandigarh, India, researchers Rani et al. (2016) discovered that “dysmenorrhea” is rather common among young women. This makes it an obvious diversion from cleaning.

This study found that “dysmenorrhea” is a complex medical condition that affects many aspects of daily life. Ahuja et al. (2016) found that teenage girls with “dysmenorrhea” struggle academically and otherwise. According to the findings, period discomfort may affect a person's comfort, learning, and well-being.
Kavitha and Jeyalakshmi (2013) study primary “dysmenorrhea”'s social and psychological effects on young women.

Workplace stress exacerbates “dysmenorrhea”'s mental and emotional effects on young women. Sangwan and Vashisht (2017) found that Haryana schoolgirls had a high rate of “dysmenorrhea”. These findings demonstrate the need for community-level illness awareness and care. These studies show that “dysmenorrhea” affects many aspects of young Indians' lives. The authors recommend researching solutions in health, psychology, and education.

4.6.3. Cultural and Social Perceptions of Menstruation

Throughout Indian history, myths, taboos, and ancient rituals have shaped the society. The national culture is built on these concepts. Chothe et al. (2014) found several menstruation myths in Pune's ethnographic research.

If people believe the wrong things, they might learn the wrong things and be socially stigmatised. This study found that cultural and social norms play a part in shaping how young girls learn about and deal with menstruation.

Traditional medicine's role in maintaining menstrual health is the subject of research by Roy et al. (2018). The results show that herbal remedies are widely used in many cultures and that scientific research on these traditional practices is relevant. Herbal formulations are widely used in India because many people believe in their effectiveness.

In their studies, Rani et al. (2016) and Ahuja (2016) touch briefly on menstruation culture. Although the primary focus of these studies was “dysmenorrhea” and its effects, they inadvertently illuminated how cultural viewpoints impact menstruation management and treatment. Cultural and social beliefs significantly affect when Indian women have their periods, according to these studies.

A thorough familiarity with these cultural factors is essential for the efficacy of menstrual health therapy. We need to promote culturally relevant health education and practices while also debunking myths and giving accurate information.

Periods in India are associated with a lot of myths and rituals as well as gender standards and social expectations and anticipations. Evidence from studies such as Chhabra et al. (2017) indicates that ideas about periods have a significant impact on premenarche education. Period stigma and myths persist due to similar information gaps.

Sangwan and Vashisht's (2017) studies found “dysmenorrhea” to be a common female symptom. This acceptance may lead to disease underreporting and treatment failure. Menstrual health is taboo for many reasons, including the belief that period pain is normal.

Recent Pune studies have illuminated the wider use of these cultural perspectives (Pandit 2014). Evidence suggests that educational institutions may lack the funds to manage menstruation health and educate students. This issue is culturally significant because our culture values women's health.

4.6.4. Healthcare Access and Coordination

Indian women have trouble getting “dysmenorrhea” treatment and medicine. Medical professionals know little about menstrual hygiene methods, according to Shukla and Sanjeev (2022). When there is a lack of comprehension, career advancement and patient teaching are separate.

This distinction means doctors and other medical professionals should focus on listening and communication skills. Further evidence that healthcare accessibility affects “dysmenorrhea” therapy has been shown by Ahuja et al. (2016) and Rani et al. (2016).

Their research shows that healthcare providers are not doing enough to alleviate menstruation cramps. Chothe et al. (2014) investigate cultural viewpoints on healthcare. This research has shown the significance of culturally competent healthcare by illuminating the ways in which prejudice and misunderstandings discourage individuals from seeking medical attention.

All of these studies add up to show that India needs a concerted effort to make “dysmenorrhea” treatment more accessible. Therapy that takes cultural norms into account, better patient education, and better healthcare worker training are all examples. The problem with healthcare access and care coordination goes beyond just a lack of services.

Pandit (2014) argues that healthcare and educational institutions should work together to raise awareness about menstrual health and improve management of periods. In this respect, he emphasises the role of educational institutions. Alternative and complementary medicine is better understood thanks to the study by Roy et al. (2018).

Findings from this study call for integration of complementary and alternative medicine practices. Given this, it is critical to have access to a healthcare system that offers a variety of treatments while also respecting people's cultural preferences.

Community involvement in healthcare solution development is highlighted by both Sangwan and Vashisht (2017) and Chhabra et al. (2017). It appears from their research that community-based initiatives can greatly improve healthcare coordination and access.

Chapter 5 – Discussion

5.1. Introduction

This systematic review critically appraises the effectiveness of different interventions for dysmenorrhea among Indian females, an area which has received insufficient attention but one with great significance.

Dysmenorrhea is a common problem among women, which seriously affects their quality of life and productivity. It plays an important role in endangering the health not only for individual patients but also has a wider impact on the society. This study is crucial in understanding the efficacy of current interventions under India's distinct socio-cultural and health care environment.

Its objective is to bring together dispersed evidence and light up the terrain of menstrual health management in India. These results will hopefully have an important role in contributing to the academic discussion, and offering healthcare workers, policymakers and educators’ better methods of dealing with this frequently overlooked women's health problem.

5.2. Critical Appraisal of Included Studies

The critical summary of the relevant research included in this review highlights a complex picture of work on dysmenorrhea in Indian women. Methodology varied among studies from qualitative, ethnographic designs to cross-sectional and comparative approaches. A remarkable variation in sample features, from ranging generations of adolescent girls to experienced gynaecologists gave a multifaceted perspective on the issue.

In Shukla and Sanjeev's (2022) cross-sectional qualitative research, gynaecologists were found to be unaware of various intricacies of feminine hygiene and related issues. However, the strength of this study's methods lie in its purposive sampling and semi-structured interviews, which adequately answers the research focus as it specifically chose to incorporate participants who were completely required as per the research focus. 

In a comparative study involving 300 adolescent girls conducted by Rani, Sharma and Singh (2016) in Chandigarh the prevalence of dysmenorrhea was found to be as high as 61.33 %. This multistage stratified sampling and interview techniques offers a solid framework for understanding how dysmenorrhea affects this particular population, as the sample selected for the qualitative assessment is considerable in terms of numbers.

Kavitha and Jeyalakshmi (2013) explore qualitatively the experiences of ten adolescent girls with primary dysmenorrhea, exposing some of the stresses that accompany this condition. The thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews confirmed both the impact on daily life and support needs these individuals faced. While, the information provided does add to the corpus of knowledge to be discussed in this systematic review, the limited sample size of 10 impairs the generalisability of the results.

Similar to Rani et al. (2016), Ahuja, Sharma and Singh's (2016) cross-sectional study in Chandigarh had the same participant demographic where dysmenorrhea was also found to have a large impact on activities and schooling. The stratified sampling and interview methodology used in this study were effective at quantifying the extent of dysmenorrhea, as well its effects. Qualitative, ethnographic study among schoolgirls in Pune by Chothe et al. (2014) provides a culturally rich understanding of perceptions about menstrual cycles.

The convenience sampling and ethnographic structure were perfect for exploring the deeply-rooted myths and health concerns surrounding menstruation. However, this sampling method also exposes a significant limitation for the results obtained by the study. Given, the use of convenience sampling, there is limitation of generalisability of the results as the selection procedure lacks randomness which could have enabled higher generalisability of the results.
Roy et al.'s (2018) inquiry into herbal formulations for dysmenorrhoeal ended a trend toward traditional medicine, testing the efficacy of numerous plant-based remedies.

This scientific rigor in their pharmacogenetic analysis gave a basis for validation of traditional medicines. However, this study is to be assessed in the light of the limitations of pharmacogenomic tests which often have to the drawback of not being able to detect rare alleles, and hence different tests are required for different alleles.

A focus group discussion on premenarchal awareness among 382 students in Central India by Chhabra et al. (2017) punctuated how early education affects a woman's experience of dysmenorrhea. This relationship was specifically investigated through interviews that used pre-designed questionnaires. Haryana menstruation-cycle study:

Of close to 800 girls Sangwan and Vashisht (2017) studied in the field, more than half complained of abdominal pain during those days. This clearly shows how important it is that we increase health awareness here. Their cross-sectional study design and interview methodology effectively reflect dysmenorrhea in this region.

Last, a cross-sectional study of adolescent students in Pune published by Pandit (2014) indicates that dysmenorrhea and premenstrual syndrome (PMS), as well the problem about insufficient health education for menstruation management. These allowed him to prepare a structure around such issues.  Shukla and Sanjeev's (2019) research, which was insightful in pointing to the lack of understanding among gynecologists about feminine hygiene, had a small sample size that may not reflect typical

Indian states and did not attempt to take into account any differences between public hospitals as opposed to private ones. This may translates into limited generalisability of the results obtained by the researcher. Rani et al. (2016) is notable for its large sample size and stratified sampling methodology, and therefore, is methodologically viable for generalisability.

But its focus on a particular age group and urban environment may limit the universality of its conclusions. Kavitha and Jeyalakshmi (2013) made valuable observations about the stress caused by primary dysmenorrhea. However, the qualitative nature and small sample size of the study require that these findings be cautiously applied to a larger population. The small sample size presents a limitation with respect to how the results may be seen in the context of the larger population of Indian females.

Methodologically similar to Rani et al. (2015), the study by Ahuja, Sharma and Singh (2016) provides complementary insight into how dysmenorrhea affects schooling. On the other hand, its similar limitations in terms of sample diversity and geographic scope apply. In terms of sample diversity, the research is limited by the fact that the study takes a small sample from a group of school age girls.

On the other hand, its geographical scope of a small city of India, limits the geographic generalisability. An in-depth ethnographic approach by Chothe et al. (2014) explored many cultural aspects of menstruation perceptions, but was limited because it adopted convenience sampling methods which may generate biased results and make them less representative than others'.

Roy et al. (2018) studied herbal formulations to explore new directions for the management of dysmenorrhea. But as it is aimed at phytochemical assessment rather than clinical effectiveness, its immediate application in the treatment of dysmenorrhea is limited. One study by Chhabra et al. (2017) emphasized the significance of premenarche education.

The systematic method provides helpful observations, but the results are limited to Central India and may not necessarily apply elsewhere as India is a very diverse nation myriads of different cultures living among the 28 states and therefore, what is applicable in Central India might not have applicability in other parts of India as the education is also impacted by the influence of the nature of the culture. Sangwan and Vashisht (2017) have gathered important data on the incidence of dysmenorrhea, with their large sample. But as a cross-sectional study it does not allow us to infer causality.

The importance of dysmenorrhea and PMS are also well researched. Pandit (2014) carried out a study on menstrual issues in adolescents in the city of Pune. But the regional focus and qualitative nature of this study may not reflect all aspects of menstrual health problems in India.

Overall, although each study presents its own crucial data for the field of dysmenorrhea research in India, their shortcomings with regard to diversity and geographic scope as well as methodologically are a reminder that further comprehensive work is needed.

5.3. Discussion of Main Findings

5.3.1. Awareness and Education on Menstrual Health

.According to Sherpa et al. (2017), most of the college women's knowledge about dysmenorrhea and seeking behaviour was moderate. This points up a crucial problem in communicating menstrual health information; it doesn't reach the young women who need to hear it. Likewise, Omidvar et al. (2016) found that a significant proportion of Indian female students had dysmenorrhea-but the methods they used to treat it were largely non-pharmacological and not evidence based on medical advice.

This inadequate use of professional medical care may be due to ignorance or cultural obstacles, which reflects an urgent need for awareness and amenability (Sridhar and Gauthami, 2017).

Majeed et al. (2022) stress that educational intervention for menstrual hygiene is very important, pointing out a marked improvement in knowledge and practice among middle school girls in India prior to starting their period. This shows that targeted educational programs have the potential to bridge knowledge gaps.

But the work of Rani et al. (2016) showed that although knowledge may exist, it does not necessarily result in optimal pain management methods all the time. This disconnect illustrates the difficulty of turning knowledge into action, demanding a broader education strategy (Rawat et al., 2023).

According to Mathiyalagen et al. (2017), in their study, more than half of the respondents did not know about menstruation before attaining puberty, and a large proportion didn't understand where blood during one's period came from or why it was released at that time. Women's lack of awareness about menstruation means that fewer women practice good personal hygiene, and thus are more prone to reproductive illnesses. Therefore, early and complete education on menstruation is important.

Yadav and Masand (2018) state that unhygienic practices made worse by a lack of education and awareness result in menstrual disorders as well as reproductive tract infections. The researchers' findings harmonize with the concept that well-managed menstrual health is intimately related to education and knowledge.

Given these results, it is clear that menstrual health publicity in India has much need of development. Collectively, the studies indicate a considerable ignorance about menstrual health and hygiene among adolescent girls and women. This gap does not just affect their bodies, but has impacts on psychological well-being and social participation.

Therefore, there is a need to design systemic multifaceted educational programs that fully take into account the unique aspects of menstrual health and provide women with information on how best to manage their own joys.

5.3.2. Impact of Dysmenorrhea on Daily Life

When considering how dysmenorrhea affects daily life, the discourse have to take into account the results of this chapter's studies where applicable and place them against an external background during assessment.

Rani et al. (2016) report on a study in Chandigarh that dysmenorrhea causes serious interference with daily life, which is consistent to some extent about the fact that many women who suffer from it also have low BMI and are underweight; therefore physical health indicators can impact both the severity of dysmenorrhea and how much this The correlation highlights the multifaceted impact of dysmenorrhea, which goes beyond physical discomfort to include general health.

Karanth and Liya (2018), pointed out that dysmenorrhea was a major cause of school absenteeism among nursing students, while Ahuja et al. (2016) focused on the academic difficulties experienced by adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea in particular. This parallel points toward the enormous educational costs of dysmenorrhea, for which not only attendance is affected but also quality of education.

That the findings of Kavitha and Jeyalakshmi (2013) on social psychological effects of dysmenorrhea were similar to those reached in Atta et al. (2016), who studied how primary dysmenorrhea affects quality of life, general well-being and stressors alone is probably no coincidence. Both studies indicate the importance of treating dysmenorrhea along multiple dimensions.

Sangwan and Vashisht’s (2017) study of high levels of dysmenorrhea among schoolgirls in Haryana, along with its impact on their daily life activities is consistent with Chauhan and Kodnani's (2016) report that adolescent girls suffering from the illness suffer low rates at attendance at school which Altogether, these findings show the degree to which dysmenorrhea can interfere with young women's education. Also Sudarshan et al. (2020) found that family history of occurrence of Dysmenorrhea is an important factor in dysmenorrhea incidence.

An important point in understanding the impact of dysmenorrhea on daily life is that its physical symptoms include backache and psychological ones, anxiety and hence the impact of the issue is multifaceted in the lives of young women (Sima et al., 2022).

In summary, the studies from this chapter of results combined with other research all point very clearly to how dysmenorrhea affects a young woman's existence in India every day. The condition afflicts not simply their physical selves but also influences psychological well-being, educational involvement and interpersonal relations.

This point highlights the necessity of an all-round, multi disciplined approach to dysmenorrhea. Health education combined with psychological support and interventions tailored for individuals are needed in order to reduce its impact on their lives as much as possible.

5.3.3. Cultural and Social Perceptions of Menstruation

Indian society pays serious consideration to traditional cultural and social conceptions about menstruation. In this context, the findings of Laksham et al. (2019) observe that menstrual problems tend not to be reported in India due to cultural factors, reducing women's quality of life. These results illustrate the effect of cultural norms on young girls 'understanding and how to manage menstruation.

Roy et al. (2018) discussed the role of traditional medicine and revealed a cultural dependence on herbal remedies in menstrual health. This preference for traditional attitudes is also reflected in Ali et al. (2022), which sheds light on the very high proportion of university students, who managed their dysmenorrhea by self-medication; a non-intuitive cultural predilection towards familiar interventions that do not require medical professionals.

Rani et al. (2016) and Ahuja (2016), which are mainly concerned with treating dysmenorrhea, nonetheless show how cultural attitudes affect methods of controlling menstruation. Armour et al. (2019) cite that the negative effect of dysmenorrhea upon academic achievement is particularly severe, and this may be exacerbated by cultural attitudes toward menstruation.

As Chhabra et al. (2017) have noted, premenarche education is powerfully influenced by myths and rites of culture. This concurs with Oluwole et al. (2020), who find that giving adolescents a better understanding of dysmenorrhea via health education increased the number seeking treatment, so when designing such programmes, it is important to dispel cultural myths. Sangwan and Vashisht (2017) pointed out that dysmenorrhea occurs frequently.

But in Indian society, period pain had always been regarded as a normal thing by the culture at large. Ní Chéileachair et al. (2022) point out that, from this viewpoint, there tend to be insufficient adjustment strategies; it leads in a circle of censorship and concealment about menstruation hygiene.

Menstrual disturbances not only have unique academic and social consequences, those effects are often exacerbated by cultural attitudes towards menstruation. Maity et al., (2022) note that proactive policies in the educational system are required to narrow this social divide and make room for menstrual health as there the authors assess the impact of proactive policies to have a positive indication.

In other words, the cultural and social meanings of menstruation in India serve to shape women 'experiences with dysmenorrhea as well as their perceptions of themselves. These perceptions often result in considerable under-reporting of menstruation problems, overuse of traditional practices or methods and an insufficient response on the part of educational institutions (Sahin et al., 2018).

These cultural factors must be taken into account if menstrual health is to be effectively managed. Health education and practice should therefore become culturally sensitive, challenging the myths that exist on this topic while providing accurate information.

5.3.4. Healthcare Access and Coordination

This discussion of the availability and coordination of healthcare in dysmenorrhea treatment reflects major gaps and opportunities for improvement, as can be seen from studies reported in Section Results (which are largely confirmed by other research).

This highlights the ignorance among medical professionals about menstrual hygiene practices, as pointed out by Shukla and Sanjeev (2022). This is, in fact-as Li et al. (2020) point out as well--a gap that slows down the process of effective patient education and care coordination among healthcare providers themselves; this further underscores the need to improve training and communication skills for such personnel.

The lack of proper care for treatment of dysmenorrhea is also further evidenced by Ahuja et al. (2016) and Rani et al. (2016). As McGovern and Cheung (2018) found, treatments such as yoga treatment that are not widely recognized in the conventional medical world can be helpful to women with primary dysmenorrhea. Chothe et al. (2014) explore the role of culture in healthcare.

Their results mirror those of Sharma et al. (2023), who found problems in obtaining healthcare for women with disabilities; culturally sensitive health care is required, and there needs to be a determination to change negative attitudes towards handicapped people that might deter them from seeking medical attention.

Pandit (2014) suggests integrating healthcare and educational institutions for raising awareness about menstrual health. The same was also expressed by Owonaro et al. (2021) who found that students 'processing of information on dysmenorrhea is affected at the individual level just as much as its occurrence involves systems-level factors such asymmetries in access to Understanding and integrating complementary-alternative medicine is observed to be a solution by Roy et al. (2018).

This is also corroborated, according to Zafar et al. (2017), who pointed out that the incidence of menstrual illness was high and its severity affected by economic status; they also noted that healthcare systems should provide a variety of treatment methods while respecting cultural preferences.

According to Sangwan and Vashisht (2017) and Chhabra et al. (2017), the primary factor in developing health care is community participation. This accords with Vanitha et al. (2017), who discovered that some four in ten rural women suffered menstrual problems, yet only a small percentage sought treatment for personal reasons, leaving an opening on the part of community-based healthcare systems to improve coordination and accessibility. However, the focus of the study on rural setting limits the adaptability and applicability of the finding in the context of urban India.

Taken together, these studies suggest that in India there needs to be more effort put into improving accessibility and coordination of dysmenorrhea treatment. This involves developing culturally sensitive therapies, strengthening patient education and increasing staff training (Armour et al., 2019).

Also, education institutions and the integration of alternative medicine into healthcare have a key place (Al Ajeel et al., 2020). And community-based initiatives also play an important role in strengthening healthcare coordination and access, including for all the diverse problems faced by women with dysmenorrhea.

Chapter 6: Conclusion

6.1. Strengths of the Systematic Review

The integrity and comprehensiveness of this systematic review rests on several key strengths that characterize its robust methodology. The search strategy of the review was carefully constructed, covering not only Scopus but also such sources as Medline and Web of Sciences.

This complete approach made possible the coverage of a wide variety of topics, lending some depth to the review. The 683 initial yields went on to become the now-refined selection of 354 unique records. This is a testament both to the depth and thoroughness of search strategy employed. Its far and wide search, apart from collecting all the different types of practices for dysmenorrhea, also afforded us a multifaceted picture of this condition in its Indian setting.

But on the other hand, those strict inclusion and exclusion criteria employed in this study have also ensured not only relevance but the quality of selected studies. The elimination of duplicates was undertaken systematically and carefully. Eleven relevant studies were reviewed in terms of their relevance, all with the rigorous methodology as background.

Given it was based on the best and most applicable research, the final analysis turned out to be quite up-to-date. But the level of care in its choice of reviewers is also reflected in the authenticity and credibility of its end result. But by bringing in studies with different socio-cultural backgrounds, the review became much more comprehensive.

Studies like those by Shukla and Sanjeev (2022); and Chothe et al. (2014) provided some insights on urban-rural differences: Menstrual health management is also affected by cultural practices. It offered a more concrete explanation for dysmenorrhea interventions in all of socio-cultural India.

To capture the regional and cultural diversity of Indian women's experience with dysmenorrhea, reviewers also included pivotal studies. In short, these advantages coupled together constitute the power of systematic review. Moreover, they prevent a narrow and unilateral perspective on dysmenorrhea treatment in India.

6.2. Limitations of the Systematic Review

A major shortcoming of the review is that it may have a geographic and cultural bias. Though an attempt was made to cover a wide range of studies, there is still some overrepresentation about certain areas (particularly urbanized ones like Chandigarh), as the research by Rani et al. (2016) and Ahuja et al. (2016).

On the other hand, underrepresentation of rural and less accessible parts of India may have biased her global understanding on dysmenorrhea interventions. If such a bias were to exist it would leave unexplored the special circumstances and concerns faced by women in these less representative areas, thus reducing the applicability of review's conclusions across India as whole.

The review's findings may also be influenced by the methodological differences between those selected studies. Qualitative approaches: Some of the studies, like cross-sectional research done by Shukla and Sanjeev (2022), provide lengthy qualitative analyses. Others may have used different forms of analysis which could affect uniformity as well as comparability among results.

Differences in methodology would mean that the depth and type of data collected also varies, which could affect how one interprets or synthesizes these findings. Further, the literature reviewed represented a limitation in its scope. This emphasis on well-established, widely used interventions may have over looked emerging or less documented treatments for dysmenorrhea.

They can risk a lack of understanding of the full range and variety possible in terms of interventions, including those that are unorthodox or newly emerging. This kind of limit makes the continuing exploration necessary, and it imperative that in future studies a wider variety of interventions are included so as to present more comprehensive India picture for dysmenorrhea management.

In short, although the systematic review provides valuable information on dysmenorrhea interventions in India, these limitations need to be taken into account when its findings and implications are being considered. In future work, tackling these limitations will be essential for any more fully-rounded appreciation of dysmenorrhea management on the Indian sub-continent.

6.3. Conclusion

6.3.1. Summary of Conclusion

This systematic review offers insight into the complex world of interventions for dysmenorrhea in India, both quantitatively and qualitatively. The results of various studies can be combined into a whole picture encompassing the effects and responses to MS.

Finally, on a more deep-seated level the survey reveals an excessive dependence on tried and true home remedies according to one study by Roy et al. (2018), with such penchants preferring locally produced treatments coming just naturally from customs.

Therefore, cultural sensitivity is crucial in intervention strategies. Furthermore, the review noted that awareness and education are necessary for dysmenorrhea management. Shukla and Sanjeev (2022) said that people didn't have knowledge about female hygiene. Chhabra et al., in 2017, reported that premenarche education had a big effect on menstrual health.

In addition, the review found that dysmenorrhea occurs in a variety of forms and can cause quite an upending to one's normal life (as illustrated by Rani et al. 2016; Ahuja et al. 2016). These studies discovered that not only is dysmenorrhea a source of physical pain, it also cuts into schooling and interferes with social life-all things which impact the quality of life for Indian women. As studies show, differences in experience between regions also imply different region-specific intervention strategies.

In sum, the review provides an overall picture of interventions for dysmenorrhea in India today. It stresses the role of education-focused, culturally sensitive methodologies that encompass both physical and psychosocial dimensions. These findings advocate a comprehensive approach to managing dysmenorrhea that takes account of the differences in culture, education and geographical location across India.

6.3.2. Alignment with Objectives

The systematic review adopts a rigorous approach corresponding to its prespecified aims. It assesses interventions against dysmenorrhea from within the Indian rubric; analyzes across various socio-cultural groups as to how these have been received and understood; explores menstrual health in general, including what is needed for women's wellbeing both actually and ideally.

Objective 1

This review scrutinizes the effectiveness of a variety of interventions for dysmenorrhea, showing an astute understanding that many are not effective in India's unique milieu. As seen in the study of Roy et al. (2018), reliance on traditional remedies is clearly dominant, consistent with cultural and social inclination to prefer natural as well as self-administerable treatments.

Likewise, modern medical interventions as introduced in the research article from Shukla and Sanjeev (2016) show a growing trend of scientifically proven methods. There are still hold-ups however due to socio-cultural traditions together with education levels. This contrast in treatment options emphasizes the necessity of context-related evidence on how effective interventions are.

Objective 2

Such findings reveal a mixed reception of dysmenorrhea interventions as they spanned India's socio-cultural range. Studies like those of Chothe et al. (2014) and Pandit (2014) show differences in acceptability which are affected by variables such as regional credos, educational attainment or class composition. This variation in receptiveness underlines the need not only for efficacious interventions but also ones that are culturally congruent and accessible to different parts of society.

Objective 3

The review stresses, first of all in terms of menstrual health and also for reasons relating to social welfare, the importance that should be attached to treating dysmenorrhea properly. All such studies prove that better menstrual health means a higher level of education and likelihood to be professionally involved, according to Rani et al. (2016), Ahuja et al. (2016). Social involvement and menstrual health equality are both beneficent signs of gender equity, but they also represent the advancement in a society as whole.

6.4. Recommendations for Practice

This qualitative systematic review has several implications for practice in healthcare settings based on its results.

Implementing Findings:

This is a review for health care professionals to help them integrate these ideas into their practice. Roy et al. (2018) and Shukla and Sanjeev (2022), for example, mention a multipronged approach to the treatment of dysmenorrhea--traditional medicines as well as modern medical care. From efficacy to compliance One needs a patient-centered method that takes into account personal demands and choices.

Cultural Sensitivity:

The review stresses the need for culturally sensitive practices in treating dysmenorrhea. Chothe et al.’s (2014) studies make clear to practitioners the socio-cultural factors of treatment decisions and health seeking behavior among low resource setting patients. Incorporating these cultural views can strengthen patient trust, the credibility of treatment.

Educational Initiatives:

The discourse has to strengthen educational work about menstrual health. According to the study by Chhabra et al. (2017), healthcare providers need to participate in community activities so as share knowledge about menstrual hygiene and health. These programs allow women and girls to make choices that are right for them when it comes to their health care, as well as have better menstrual experiences.

6.5. Recommendations for Research

Many important areas need to be researched concerning interventions for dysmenorrhea, and this systematic review provides a good starting point.

Further Studies:

Future research should focus on interventions and populations that have been under explored. These involve evaluating the efficacy of newly developed non-pharmaceutical treatments and their suitability to different Indian socio-cultural settings. Research on rural populations, traditionally underrepresented in studies, is especially important as it gives us a more comprehensive idea of dysmenorrhea management all across India.

Methodological Improvements:

Future studies on dysmenorrhea urgently need to refine research methodologies. Mixed-method approaches could yield richer, more complete insights. As Chothe et al. (2014) have shown in their studies, incorporating participatory research methods can provide more profound and complex understanding of dysmenorrhea as seen from the point of view of women who experience it themselves.

Longitudinal Research:

The review points out that there is a pressing need for systematic, long-term studies to evaluate the effectiveness and impact of interventions aimed at dysmenorrhea.

These kinds of study are sorely needed to determine whether the effects of these maternal interventions are actually sustained in terms of menstrual health, educational attainment and overall quality life--in other words what benefits they bring with them on a long-term basis.

6.6. Self-reflection

During this research process, my understanding of the complexity of dysmenorrhea and its treatment in India has increased much. From this I have gleaned much in the relationship of cultural practices, access to medical care and women's own efforts at educating themselves about menstrual health.

However, the process was not without difficulties. With myriads of studies, and each with its own methodological approaches, precise analysis and critical thinking were needed. This was a daunting task, but it has sharpened my research skills and enriched in me an appreciation for the subtlety of qualitative research.

Looking forward, this research lays the groundwork for my future academic and professional work. It has kindled an ardor for women's health, and shown the value of culturally sensitive medicine.

I am now much more sensitive to the challenges of delivering health care in various cultural contexts, and feel inspired that my experience may add something unique. Perhaps later attention should be turned back to research on women's health which has long been neglected.
 

Top Healthcare Samples
 

References

Abhijna, J. and Shetty, V., 2023. A Comparative Study on the Effect of Acupuncture and Neutral Hip Bath among Young Females with Primary “dysmenorrhea” –A Prospective Randomised Trial. Chettinad Health City Medical Journal (E-2278-2044 & P-2277-8845), 12(1), pp.10-16.
Agrawal, R. and Ahmed, R., 2021. A Comparative Study of Stretching Exercises Versus Core Strengthening Exercises on Primary “dysmenorrhea” in Young Sedentary Females. European Journal of Biomedical, 8(8), pp.368-374.
Ahuja, A., Sharma, M.K. and Singh, A., 2016. Impact of “dysmenorrhea” on quality of life of adolescent girls of Chandigarh. J Child Adolesc Behav, 4(295), p.2.
Al Ajeel, L.Y., Chong, M.C., Tang, L.Y., Wong, L.P. and Al Raimi, A.M., 2020. The Effect of Health Education on Knowledge and Self-Care Among Arabic Schoolgirls With Primary Dysmenorrhea in Malaysia. The Journal for Nurse Practitioners, 16(10), pp.762-767.
Ali, A., Ali, A., Alotaibi, N.S., Alsufyani, M.S., Alotaibi, A.J., Almutairi, M.M. and Eldalo, A.S., 2022. Prevalence, impact, and management perception of “dysmenorrhea” among university students: A cross-sectional study. Brazilian Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, 58.
AlRyalat, S.A.S., Malkawi, L.W. and Momani, S.M., 2019. Comparing bibliometric analysis using PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science databases. JoVE (Journal of Visualized Experiments), (152), p.e58494.
Amir-Behghadami, M., 2021. SPIDER as a framework to formulate eligibility criteria in qualitative systematic reviews. BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care.
Armour, M., Parry, K., Al-Dabbas, M.A., Curry, C., Holmes, K., MacMillan, F., Ferfolja, T. and Smith, C.A., 2019. Self-care strategies and sources of knowledge on menstruation in 12,526 young women with “dysmenorrhea”: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One, 14(7), p.e0220103.
Armour, M., Parry, K., Manohar, N., Holmes, K., Ferfolja, T., Curry, C., MacMillan, F. and Smith, C.A., 2019. The prevalence and academic impact of “dysmenorrhea” in 21,573 young women: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of women's health, 28(8), pp.1161-1171.
Armour, M., Parry, K., Manohar, N., Holmes, K., Ferfolja, T., Curry, C., MacMillan, F. and Smith, C.A., 2019. The prevalence and academic impact of dysmenorrhea in 21,573 young women: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of women's health, 28(8), pp.1161-1171.
Arora, A., Yardi, S. and Gopal, S., 2014. Effect of 12-weeks of aerobic exercise on primary dysmennorrhea. Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy, 8(3), p.130. 
Atta, K., Jawed, S. and Zia, S., 2016. Correlating primary “dysmenorrhea” with its stressors: a cross sectional study investigating the most likely factors of primary “dysmenorrhea” and its effects on quality of life and general well being. Journal of University Medical & Dental College, 7(4).
Babbar, K., Martin, J., Ruiz, J., Parray, A.A. and Sommer, M., 2022. Menstrual health is a public health and human rights issue. The Lancet Public Health, 7(1), pp.e10-e11.
Seif, M.W., Diamond, K. and Nickkho-Amiry, M., 2015. Obesity and menstrual disorders. Best Practice & Research Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 29(4), pp.516-527.
Bahamondes, L. and Ali, M., 2015. Recent advances in managing and understanding menstrual disorders. F1000prime reports, 7.
Bleiker, J., Morgan-Trimmer, S., Knapp, K. and Hopkins, S., 2019. Navigating the maze: Qualitative research methodologies and their philosophical foundations. Radiography, 25, pp.S4-S8.
Boland, A., Dickson, R. and Cherry, G., 2017. Doing a systematic review: A student's guide. Doing a Systematic Review, pp.1-304.
Bramer, W.M., De Jonge, G.B., Rethlefsen, M.L., Mast, F. and Kleijnen, J., 2018. A systematic approach to searching: an efficient and complete method to develop literature searches. Journal of the Medical Library Association: JMLA, 106(4), p.531.
Bramer, W.M., Rethlefsen, M.L., Kleijnen, J. and Franco, O.H., 2017. Optimal database combinations for literature searches in systematic reviews: a prospective exploratory study. Systematic reviews, 6, pp.1-12. 
Buccheri, R.K. and Sharifi, C., 2017. Critical appraisal tools and reporting guidelines for evidence‐based practice. Worldviews on Evidence‐Based Nursing, 14(6), pp.463-472.
Chaudhuri, A., Singh, A. and Dhaliwal, L., 2013. A randomised controlled trial of exercise and hot water bottle in the management of dysmenorrhoea in school girls of Chandigarh, India. Indian J Physiol Pharmacol, 57(2), pp.114-122.
Chauhan, G. and Kodnani, A.H., 2016. A study of prevalence and impact of “dysmenorrhea” and its associated symptoms among adolescent girls residing in slum areas of Vadodara city, Gujarat. Int J Med Sci Public Health, 5(3), p.510.
Chen, C., 2017. Science mapping: a systematic review of the literature. Journal of data and information science, 2(2), pp.1-40.
Chhabra, S., Gokhale, S. and Yadav, S., 2017. Premenarche information and “dysmenorrhea” in young girls. Insights Reprod Med, 1(2), pp.1-6.
Chothe, V., Khubchandani, J., Seabert, D., Asalkar, M., Rakshe, S., Firke, A., Midha, I. and Simmons, R., 2014. Students’ perceptions and doubts about menstruation in developing countries: a case study from India. Health promotion practice, 15(3), pp.319-326.
Cumpston, M., Li, T., Page, M.J., Chandler, J., Welch, V.A., Higgins, J.P. and Thomas, J., 2019. Updated guidance for trusted systematic reviews: a new edition of the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. The Cochrane database of systematic reviews, 2019(10).
Desai, R.G., 2022. Physiotherapy Intervention for Primary “dysmenorrhea”-A Narrative Review. International Journal of Research and Review, 9(3), pp.441-449.
Feizi, A. and Soheili, A., 2021. Spider: An Optimal Framework For Retrieval Of Best Qualitative Evidence. Nursing And Midwifery Journal, 18(11), pp.840-847.
Feng, X. and Wang, X., 2018. Comparison of the efficacy and safety of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs for patients with primary “dysmenorrhea”: A network meta-analysis. Molecular pain, 14, p.1744806918770320.
Gotpagar, M.T. and Devi, P., 2020. Effect of Bosu Pilates on Primary “dysmenorrhea” in Adolescent Girls. Indian Journal of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology, 14(3).
Gurpreet, K., Jaspreet, K. and Ravneet, K., 2018. The effect of exercises in primary “dysmenorrhea” among young females of Adesh University. Indian J Physiother Occup Ther, 12(3), pp.112-116.
Gusenbauer, M. and Haddaway, N.R., 2020. Which academic search systems are suitable for systematic reviews or meta‐analyses? Evaluating retrieval qualities of Google Scholar, PubMed, and 26 other resources. Research synthesis methods, 11(2), pp.181-217.
Hannes, K. and Bennett, S., 2017. Understanding evidence from qualitative research. Evidence-based practice across the health professions, pp.226-247.
Jedynak, B., Jaworska-Zaremba, M., Grzechocińska, B., Chmurska, M., Janicka, J. and Kostrzewa-Janicka, J., 2021. TMD in females with menstrual disorders. International journal of environmental research and public health, 18(14), p.7263.
Karanth, S. and Liya, S.R., 2018. Prevalence and risk factors for dysmenorrhoea among nursing student and its impact on their quality of life. Int J Reprod Contracept Obstet Gynecol, 7(7), pp.2661-2667.
Kaur, A., Ray, G. and Mitra, M., 2017. Comparing the effectiveness of connective tissue mobilisation and kinesio-taping on females with primary “dysmenorrhea”. Indian Journal of Physiotherapy & Occupational Therapy, 11, pp.70-5.
Kavitha, C. and Jeyalakshmi, S., 2013. Explore the Lived Experiences of Adolescent Girls on Perceived Experiences of Stress due to Primary Dysmenorrhoea. Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development, 5(4), p.311.
Kim, H., Sefcik, J.S. and Bradway, C., 2017. Characteristics of qualitative descriptive studies: A systematic review. Research in nursing & health, 40(1), pp.23-42.
Kural, M., Noor, N.N., Pandit, D., Joshi, T. and Patil, A., 2015. Menstrual characteristics and prevalence of “dysmenorrhea” in college going girls. Journal of family medicine and primary care, 4(3), p.426.
Lakkawar, N.J., Jayavani, R.L., Arthi, P.N., Alaganandam, P. and Vanajakshi, N., 2014. A study of menstrual disorders in medical students and its correlation with biological variables. Sch J App Med Sci, 2(6E), pp.3165-75.
Laksham, K.B., Selvaraj, R. and Kar, S.S., 2019. Menstrual disorders and quality of life of women in an urban area of Puducherry: a community-based cross-sectional study. Journal of family medicine and primary care, 8(1), p.137.
Li, A.D., Bellis, E.K., Girling, J.E., Jayasinghe, Y.L., Grover, S.R., Marino, J.L. and Peate, M., 2020. Unmet needs and experiences of adolescent girls with heavy menstrual bleeding and “dysmenorrhea”: a qualitative study. Journal of Pediatric and Adolescent Gynecology, 33(3), pp.278-284.
Lohani, P., 2019. Prevalence and determinants of menstrual disorders and napkin usage among women in India using DLHS-4 data. Journal of family medicine and primary care, 8(6), p.2106.
Long, H.A., French, D.P. and Brooks, J.M., 2020. Optimising the value of the critical appraisal skills programme (CASP) tool for quality appraisal in qualitative evidence synthesis. Research Methods in Medicine & Health Sciences, 1(1), pp.31-42.
Ma, L.L., Wang, Y.Y., Yang, Z.H., Huang, D., Weng, H. and Zeng, X.T., 2020. Methodological quality (risk of bias) assessment tools for primary and secondary medical studies: what are they and which is better?. Military Medical Research, 7, pp.1-11.
Maity, S., Wray, J., Coffin, T., Nath, R., Nauhria, S., Sah, R., Waechter, R., Ramdass, P. and Nauhria, S., 2022. Academic and social impact of menstrual disturbances in female medical students: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Frontiers in medicine, 9, p.821908.
Majeed, J., Sharma, P., Ajmera, P., & Dalal, K. (2022). Menstrual hygiene practices and associated factors among Indian adolescent girls: a meta-analysis. Reproductive Health, 19(1), 1-13.
Majid, U. and Vanstone, M., 2018. Appraising qualitative research for evidence syntheses: a compendium of quality appraisal tools. Qualitative health research, 28(13), pp.2115-2131.
Mathiyalagen, P., Peramasamy, B., Vasudevan, K., Basu, M., Cherian, J. and Sundar, B., 2017. A descriptive cross-sectional study on menstrual hygiene and perceived reproductive morbidity among adolescent girls in a union territory, India. Journal of family medicine and primary care, 6(2), p.360.
McGovern, C.E. and Cheung, C., 2018. Yoga and quality of life in women with primary “dysmenorrhea”: a systematic review. Journal of midwifery & women's health, 63(4), pp.470-482.
Mohapatra, D., Mishra, T., Behera, M. and Panda, P., 2016. A study of relation between body mass index and “dysmenorrhea” and its impact on daily activities of medical students. Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical and Clinical Research, pp.297-299.
Munn, Z., Peters, M.D., Stern, C., Tufanaru, C., McArthur, A. and Aromataris, E., 2018. Systematic review or scoping review? Guidance for authors when choosing between a systematic or scoping review approach. BMC medical research methodology, 18, pp.1-7.
Munn, Z., Stern, C., Aromataris, E., Lockwood, C. and Jordan, Z., 2018. What kind of systematic review should I conduct? A proposed typology and guidance for systematic reviewers in the medical and health sciences. BMC medical research methodology, 18(1), pp.1-9.
Munro, M.G., Critchley, H.O., Fraser, I.S., FIGO Menstrual Disorders Committee, Haththotuwa, R., Kriplani, A., Bahamondes, L., Füchtner, C., Tonye, R., Archer, D. and Abbott, J., 2018. The two FIGO systems for normal and abnormal uterine bleeding symptoms and classification of causes of abnormal uterine bleeding in the reproductive years: 2018 revisions. International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics, 143(3), pp.393-408.
Nayak, S.G., George, D.L.S., Assariparambil, A.R., George, A., Rao, D.K.S., K, D.A., Bhat, D.V.R. and N, D.R., 2022. Meditation and yoga impact on “dysmenorrhea” (MY-ID): a study protocol. F1000Research, 11, p.590.
Ní Chéileachair, F., McGuire, B.E. and Durand, H., 2022. Coping with “dysmenorrhea”: a qualitative analysis of period pain management among students who menstruate. BMC Women's Health, 22(1), p.407.
Oluwole, E.O., Agha, O.O., Ogunyemi, A. and Bakare, O.Q., 2020. Perception and Healthcare seeking practices regarding “dysmenorrhea” among public secondary school students in Lagos, Nigeria: Prevalence and healthcare seeking practice of “dysmenorrhea” among secondary school adolescents. Babcock University Medical Journal, 3(2), pp.34-44.
Omidvar, S., Bakouei, F., Amiri, F. N., & Begum, K. (2016). Primary “dysmenorrhea” and menstrual symptoms in Indian female students: prevalence, impact and management. Global journal of health science, 8(8), 135.
Omidvar, S., Nasiri-Amiri, F., Bakhtiari, A. and Begum, K., 2019. Clinical trial for the management “dysmenorrhea” using selected spices. Complementary therapies in clinical practice, 36, pp.34-38.
Owonaro, P.A., Arute, J.E., Uweru, B.C. and Eniojukan, J.F., 2021. Health seeking behavior among tertiary school female students with “dysmenorrhea” in Delta State, South-South, Nigeria.
Paithankar, S.M. and Hande, D., 2016. Effectiveness of pilates over conventional physiotherapeutic treatment in females with primary dysmmenorrhea. IOSR-JDMS, 15, pp.156-63.
Pandit, S.B., 2014. Common Menstrual Problems among Adolescent students. Sinhgad e Journal of Nursing, 4.
Papaioannou, D., Sutton, A. and Booth, A., 2016. Systematic approaches to a successful literature review. Systematic approaches to a successful literature review, pp.1-336.
Patel, N.S., Tanna, T. and Bhatt, S., 2015. Effect of active stretching exercises on primary “dysmenorrhea” in college going female students. Indian J Physiother Occup Ther, 9(3), pp.72-76.
Pati, D. and Lorusso, L.N., 2018. How to write a systematic review of the literature. HERD: Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 11(1), pp.15-30.
Prabhu, S., Nagrale, S., Shyam, A. and Sancheti, P., 2019. Effect of yogasanas on menstrual cramps in young adult females with primary “dysmenorrhea”. Int J Physiother Res, 7(4), pp.3129-3134.
Purssell, E., 2020. Can the critical appraisal skills programme check‐lists be used alongside grading of recommendations assessment, development and evaluation to improve transparency and decision‐making?. Journal of advanced nursing, 76(4), pp.1082-1089.
Quigley, J.M., Thompson, J.C., Halfpenny, N.J. and Scott, D.A., 2019. Critical appraisal of nonrandomised studies—a review of recommended and commonly used tools. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 25(1), pp.44-52.
Rani, A., Sharma, M.K. and Singh, A., 2016. Practices and perceptions of adolescent girls regarding the impact of “dysmenorrhea” on their routine life: a comparative study in the urban, rural, and slum areas of Chandigarh. International journal of adolescent medicine and health, 28(1), pp.3-9.
Rawat, M., Shields, A.N., Venetis, M.K. and Seth, J., 2023. Women’s agentic role in enabling and dismantling menstrual health taboos in northern india: A culture-centered approach. Health Communication, 38(4), pp.695-704.
Rogers, S.K., Galloway, A., Hirsh, A.T., Zapolski, T., Chen, C.X. and Rand, K.L., 2023. Efficacy of psychological interventions for “dysmenorrhea”: a meta-analysis. Pain Medicine, p.pnad058.
Roy, P., Mandal, P., Panda, S., Roy, S.M. and Subba, A., 2018. Pharmacognosy and phytochemical screening of some plant derived medicine to treat “dysmenorrhea”l pain by the Rajbanshi Community. Pharmacognosy Journal, 10(4).
Ryan, S.A., 2017. The treatment of “dysmenorrhea”. Pediatric Clinics, 64(2), pp.331-342.
Sahin, N., Kasap, B., Kirli, U., Yeniceri, N. and Topal, Y., 2018. Assessment of anxiety-depression levels and perceptions of quality of life in adolescents with dysmenorrhea. Reproductive health, 15(1), pp.1-7.
Sangwan, G. and Vashisht, B.M., 2017. Menstrual pattern and prevalence of “dysmenorrhea” among school going adolescent girls in a rural block of Haryana: A cross sectional study. GJMEDPH, 6(2), pp.1-5.
Shah, M., Monga, A., Patel, S.V., Shah, M. and Bakshi, H., 2016. Pain relief in “dysmenorrhea”: Exploring hypnosis as an alternative therapy. Chrismed: Journal of Health & Research, 3(3).
Sharma, R., Kumar, A., Suri, V., Kaur, S. and Singh, A.J., 2023. An integrated qualitative and quantitative study on sexual and reproductive health problems faced by women with disabilities in Chandigarh, India. International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics.
Sherpa, S.Z., Devi, R., Dangol, M.A., Limbu, A., Chettri, I., Gurung, J., Poudyal, J., Bhutia, L., Bhutia, L., Gurung, N. and Chettri, P., 2017. Knowledge Regarding “dysmenorrhea” and its Health Seeking Behavior in Colleges of Sikkim. Asian Journal of Nursing Education and Research, 7(4), pp.477-481.
Shukla, S. and Sanjeev, R., 2022. Prerogative on Women Health: A Qualitative Study on Feminine Hygiene Practices in India.
Sima, R.M., Sulea, M., Radosa, J.C., Findeklee, S., Hamoud, B.H., Popescu, M., Gorecki, G.P., Bobircă, A., Bobirca, F., Cirstoveanu, C. and Ples, L., 2022, January. The prevalence, management and impact of dysmenorrhea on medical students’ lives—A multicenter study. In Healthcare (Vol. 10, No. 1, p. 157). MDPI.
Sivadasan, S., Ali, A.N., Marimuthu, K., Nazer, Z.A., Chigurupati, S. and Veerasamy, R., 2014. Menstrual disorders among students-an overview. Research Journal of Pharmacy and Technology, 7(6), p.704.
Snyder, H., 2019. Literature review as a research methodology: An overview and guidelines. Journal of business research, 104, pp.333-339.
Sridhar, D. and Gauthami, N., 2017. Menstrual health status and cultural practices of tribal adolescent girls. Int J Commun Med Publ Health, 4(11), pp.4120-4124.
Stella Adaora, N., Suresh, A., Mohan, P., Ali, Z., Cardoza, J.V. and Bitra, M., 2021. A Study on Effects of Aerobic Exercises on Quality of Life in Primary “dysmenorrhea” in Bangalore. NVEO-NATURAL VOLATILES & ESSENTIAL OILS Journal| NVEO, pp.5304-5312.
Sudarshan, B.P., Muralidhar, M., Maoroof, A., Abhirami, S., Somina, A., Thamanna, P.A. and Thomas, T., 2020. “dysmenorrhea”–Its Prevalence, Determinants and Impact: A Cross-Sectional Study from a Medical College in North Kerala. Annals of Community Health, 8(1), pp.15-19.
Tewani, S., Sharma, H., Tewani, G.R., Kodali, P.B., Nair, P.M. and Kodali, P., 2023. The Long-Term Impact of Therapeutic Fasting on Primary “dysmenorrhea” in Young Female Adults: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Cureus, 15(7).
Tharani, G., Dharshini, E., Rajalaxmi, V., Kamatchi, K. and Vaishnavi, G., 2018. To compare the effects of stretching exercise versus aerobic dance in primary “dysmenorrhea” among collegiates. Drug Invention Today, 10(1), pp.2844-2848.
Thomas, J., Utley, J., Hong, S.Y., Korkmaz, H. and Nugent, G., 2020. A Review of the Research. Handbook of Research on STEM Education.
Unnisa, H., Annam, P., Gubba, N.C., Begum, A. and Thatikonda, K., 2022. Assessment of quality of life and effect of non-pharmacological management in “dysmenorrhea”. Annals of Medicine and Surgery, 81, p.104407.
Vanitha, D., Edward, S., Varadharajan, S. and Rani, M.A., 2017. A community based study on menstrual disorders among the rural women of reproductive age. International Journal of Women’s Health and Reproduction Sciences, 5(4), pp.270-276.
Xiao, Y. and Watson, M., 2019. Guidance on conducting a systematic literature review. Journal of planning education and research, 39(1), pp.93-112.
Yadav, A. and Masand, D.L., 2018. Study of menstrual disorder in adolescent girls at tertiary care centre in rural area. International Journal of Reproduction, Contraception, Obstetrics and Gynecology, 7(5), pp.1979-1984.0
Zafar, I., Wali, A., Kunwar, M.A., Afzal, N. and Raza, M., 2023. A pipeline for medical literature search and its evaluation. Journal of Information Science, p.01655515231161557.
Zafar, M., Sadeeqa, S., Latif, S. and Afzal, H., 2017. Pattern and prevalence of menstrual disorders in adolescents. International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research, 9(5).

Appendices

Appendix 1 – CASP Quality Assessment Table